Horace Dediu Has Some Good Questions for Apple CEO Tim Cook

Posted May 25, 2013 at 12:41am by iClarified | Please help us and submit a translation by clicking here | 7090 views

Horace Dediu, a popular Apple analyst from Asymco, has posted some questions he would like to see asked of Apple CEO Tim Cook at the upcoming AllThingsD conference.

Cook is set to kick off the 11th D: All Things Digital conference with an interview on opening night, May 28th. He will likely be speaking to Walt Mossberg and Kara Swisher but Dediu has some questions he would like answered.

-----
1. Why is the iPhone not sold as a portfolio product? Meaning, why, after six years, is there no iPhone product range being updated on a regular basis. Having a portfolio strategy is not only followed by every phone vendor but also by Apple for all its other product lines, including the iPad, which came after the iPhone. In other words, please explain why the iPhone is anomalous from a product portfolio point of view.

2. There are more than 800 operators world-wide so why are there only about 250 of them carrying your phone? Competitors large and small (from BlackBerry to Nokia to Samsung) have cited relationships with more than 500 operators so Apple is being uniquely selective. My question does not stem from a lack of patience: this total number of iPhone distributors has not increased markedly for over a year. Are you limiting distribution through conditions placed on operators (like the availability of sufficient quality data services) or are operators finding the distribution agreement too onerous (e.g. too high a minimum order quota)?

3. In 2012 Apple’s capital spending has reached the extraordinary level of $10 billion/yr, higher than all but the most capital-intensive semiconductor manufacturers. This is unusual for Apple as it was less than $1 billion in the year before the iPhone launched. It’s also unusual for Apple’s competitors in phones, PCs or tablets. It’s on a level matched only by semiconductor heavyweights. What is the purpose of this spending and what should we read into it leveling off at $10 billion for 2013?

4. Depending on one supplier is an operational faux pas, and yet Apple has found itself in that situation with Samsung for mobile microprocessors. It may be excusable in PCs with Intel having an architectural monopoly but it’s not excusable for a chip that you designed yourself and purchase in massive quantities. Why did you give Samsung such a concession, especially knowing their potential as a competitor vis-à-vis alternative suppliers who had no such potential? Does the answer have something to do with the previous question?
-----

We think these are great questions and it turns out that they might actually get asked. Kara Swisher tweeted to Dediu saying:

@jkohlmann @waltmossberg @asymco a little in the weeds, but will consider

Read More


Share
Add Comment
Leo - May 27, 2013 at 2:01am
Porra Ismael!!! deixa de mumbo jumbo e fala alguma coisa útil.
ISMAEL SANTOS - May 25, 2013 at 9:53pm
MR. HORACE DEIDU. PLEASE ASK MR. COOK AND APPLE WHEN IOS 7 COME OUT. PEOPLE HERE MAKE FUN OF ME BUT. I LOVE YOU. THIS IS REALLY. ME THE PROOF IS I AM WRITING. ALL IN CAPS AND PUTTING. PERIODS KINDA WHERE I FEEL. LIKE IT. THANK. YOU.
Follow iClarified