
Apple Files Objection to DOJ E-Book Settlement, Calls It 'Unlawful'
Posted August 16, 2012 at 6:40am by
Shalom Levytam
Apple has filed a strongly worded objection to the Department of Justice's settlement with three book publishers calling it 'unlawful', reports PaidContent.
The company file a memo with the Southern District of New York stating that the settlement, which would force it to tear up its contracts with publishers, is "fundamentally unfair, unlawful, and unprecedented." Since Apple isn't settling it says it is entitled to a trial.
"Apple is taking a bold stance by ignoring the Judge's admonition to the parties not to oppose the settlement, other than submitting comments," attorney and RoyaltyShare CEO Bob Kohn, who is seeking permission to file an amicus brief in the case, told PaidContent. "Apple makes a good point that the proposed settlement terminates Apple's agency contracts without a trial and that would be an unprecedented violation of Apple's right to due process."
The DOJ reached a settlement with HarperCollins, Hachette and Simon & Schuster in an investigation that alleges Apple and publishers conspired to fix the prices of electronic books.
"The Government is seeking to impose a remedy on Apple before there has been any finding of an antitrust violation," says Apple. They note that this case revolves around "an alleged conspiracy to force Amazon to adopt agency" thus a settlement "enjoining collusion or precluding publishers from forcing agency on Amazon would be appropriate".
The company file a memo with the Southern District of New York stating that the settlement, which would force it to tear up its contracts with publishers, is "fundamentally unfair, unlawful, and unprecedented." Since Apple isn't settling it says it is entitled to a trial.
"Apple is taking a bold stance by ignoring the Judge's admonition to the parties not to oppose the settlement, other than submitting comments," attorney and RoyaltyShare CEO Bob Kohn, who is seeking permission to file an amicus brief in the case, told PaidContent. "Apple makes a good point that the proposed settlement terminates Apple's agency contracts without a trial and that would be an unprecedented violation of Apple's right to due process."
The DOJ reached a settlement with HarperCollins, Hachette and Simon & Schuster in an investigation that alleges Apple and publishers conspired to fix the prices of electronic books.
"The Government is seeking to impose a remedy on Apple before there has been any finding of an antitrust violation," says Apple. They note that this case revolves around "an alleged conspiracy to force Amazon to adopt agency" thus a settlement "enjoining collusion or precluding publishers from forcing agency on Amazon would be appropriate".
![OpenAI Launches GPT-6.2 Astra and Sol With Better Performance, Lower Costs [Video] OpenAI Launches GPT-6.2 Astra and Sol With Better Performance, Lower Costs [Video]](/images/news/103626/103626/103626-160.jpg)

![iFixit Finds Apple HomeView Unnecessarily Difficult to Repair [Video] iFixit Finds Apple HomeView Unnecessarily Difficult to Repair [Video]](/images/news/103617/103617/103617-160.jpg)


![How To Back Up Your iPhone to an External Drive on Mac [Video] How To Back Up Your iPhone to an External Drive on Mac [Video]](/images/tutorials/72786/72786/72786-160.jpg)
![How To Sideload Apps Onto Your iPhone Using Xcode [Video] How To Sideload Apps Onto Your iPhone Using Xcode [Video]](/images/tutorials/52314/52314/52314-160.jpg)
![How To Find Your IP Address on iPhone [Video] How To Find Your IP Address on iPhone [Video]](/images/tutorials/496/496/496-160.jpg)


![MacBook Neo Drops to $649.99 ($49 Off) [Deal] MacBook Neo Drops to $649.99 ($49 Off) [Deal]](/images/news/103599/103599/103599-160.jpg)
![15-Inch M5 MacBook Air Drops to $1,249.99 ($249 Off) [Deal] 15-Inch M5 MacBook Air Drops to $1,249.99 ($249 Off) [Deal]](/images/news/103563/103563/103563-160.jpg)
![Apple Watch Series 12 Drops to New All-Time Low of $329 ($70 Off) [Deal] Apple Watch Series 12 Drops to New All-Time Low of $329 ($70 Off) [Deal]](/images/news/103548/103548/103548-160.jpg)
![AirPods Pro 3 Drop Back to $179.99 ($69 Off) [Deal] AirPods Pro 3 Drop Back to $179.99 ($69 Off) [Deal]](/images/news/103545/103545/103545-160.jpg)
