Apple Presents Closing Arguments in E-Book Price Fixing Trial

Posted June 21, 2013 at 12:50am by iClarified | Please help us and submit a translation by clicking here | 5715 views

The Department of Justice e-book price fixing case against Apple wrapped up today with closing arguments from both sides, reports AllThingsD.

Apple's lead counsel Orin Snyder argued that the agency not only failed to meet its burden of proof but overreached by seeking to prosecute Apple for legitimate business practices.

“Apple did not conspire with a single publisher to fix prices in the e-book industry,” Snyder said, arguing that the negotiations under scrutiny in this case were nothing more than “standard, lawful business activity.” And the DOJ’s claim that they were more than that, a nefarious plot over which Apple served as ringmaster, is entirely unsupported. “All of the government’s evidence is ambiguous at best,” Snyder argued, lambasting the DOJ’s case as one built on “word games and inferences.”

Apple says it didn't force Amazon or anyone else to adopt an "agency" e-book pricing model; rather, it moved to further its own legal business goals by embracing an agency model already considered by others. Snyder said that publishers and retailers did the same.

He also noted that while the DOJ has been claiming “where there’s smoke, there’s fire”, that's a theatrical smoke bomb rather than a destructive fire. Synder said that accepting that as truth and ruling against Apple would have “a chilling and confounding effect not only on commerce, but through content markets across the country.”

Apple closed its arguments by showing an iPad with the text “It’s time to close the book on this case.”

Read More




Share
Add Comment
Follow iClarified
Apple to Partner With Nordstrom on New Payments Platform?
Nordstrom is reportedly in talks with Apple t...
Apple Seeds iCloud for Windows Beta with iCloud Drive Support to AppleSeed Members
Office for iPad Now Supports Monthly Subscriptions
Microsoft has announced that Office for iPad ...
Amazon Cloud Drive Photos App Now Lets You View Metadata, Rename Albums, Stream via AirPlay
Plants vs. Zombies 2 Brings Back the Vasebreaker Mini-Game
Plants vs. Zombies 2 has been updated to brin...