New MacBook Pro Is Unstable With 8GB RAM

Posted October 24, 2008 at 7:35pm by iClarified | Please help us and submit a translation by clicking here | 9040 views

Testing suggests that the New MacBook Pro hardware can handle 8GB of RAM; however, there are OS-level limitations that cause instability.

Luke from iFixIt.com tested the new MacBook Pro with 8GB of RAM and posted the following on MacRumors

-----
We did some more testing and found some interesting things. We have not succeeded to go beyond the 4GB limit with any OS X GUI app. With a C app (eatmem) that does not use Apple's APIs, we were able to allocate 8 GB and have it reported in Activity Monitor (and top).

The C app was able to allocate up to 8 GB without paging to disk. However, OS X is not happy running at or above the 4 GB limit. Performance is very erratic, and we crashed OS X and Parallels multiple times.


8 GB allocated, the system crashed shortly thereafter.

Interestingly, when we booted Ubuntu on the machine it only reported 3 GB memory total. We don't have an explanation for that.

Overall, our testing showed that the system is unstable at 8 GB of RAM. Parallels takes forever to load, even when using
We then yanked a chip to do a comparison with 4 GB. With a single 4 GB chip, everything seems happy.

We then added a 1 GB chip for 5 GB total. We were able to get GUI apps to use all 5 GB and the system hasn't crashed on us yet. It will take more testing to determine how stable this configuration is.

We suspect that this testing implies a two things:
1) The hardware can handle a 4 GB chip without any problem
2) There are OS-level limitations with 8 GB RAM on these systems.

Luke Soules
iFixit Labs
-----

Read More

Share
Add Comment
Jash Sayani - October 25, 2008 at 2:46am
Hpw about 4GB RAM on the MacBook... Is it stable..??
Follow iClarified
MythBusters Explain Gorilla Glass and Demonstrate Its Strength [Video]
Adam Savage and Jamie Hyneman of MythBusters ...
The iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus Are Capable of Playing Back 4K Video
The iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus are reportedly...
You Can Now Upload to the iCloud.com Photos Beta
Apple has updated the public online iCloud Ph...
Apple Gets Final Approval on 'Highly Unusual' $450 Million E-Book Settlement
Amazon's Black Friday Deals Start Today
Amazon has announced that its Black Friday de...