November 30, 2022
Apple Says iPhone Jailbreaking is Illegal

Apple Says iPhone Jailbreaking is Illegal

Posted February 13, 2009 at 1:08pm by iClarified · 17203 views
Jailbreaking an iPhone constitutes copyright infringement and a DMCA violation, says Apple in comments filed with the Copyright Office as part of the 2009 DMCA triennial rulemaking. This marks the first formal public statement by Apple about its legal stance on iPhone jailbreaking.

EFF, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, confronts cutting-edge issues defending free speech, privacy, innovation, and consumer rights today. The foundation has asked the Copyright Office to officially exempt jailbreaking from Apple's DMCA claims stating that this sort of claim is absurd. Imagine GM trying to claim that only GM could do any mechanical work on your car. You can read the whole article below...

Apple's iPhone, now the best-selling cellular phone in the U.S., has been designed with restrictions that prevent owners from running applications obtained from sources other than Apple's own iTunes App Store. "Jailbreaking" is the term used for removing these restrictions, thereby liberating your phone from Apple's software "jail." Estimates put the number of iPhone owners who have jailbroken their phones in the hundreds of thousands.

As part of the 2009 DMCA rulemaking, EFF has asked the Copyright Office to recognize an exemption to the DMCA to permit jailbreaking in order to allow iPhone owners to use their phones with applications that are not available from Apple's store (e.g., turn-by-turn directions, using the iPhone camera for video, laptop tethering).

Apple's copyright infringement claim starts with the observation that jailbroken iPhones depend on modified versions of Apple's bootloader and operating system software. True enough -- we said as much in our technical white paper describing the jailbreak process. But the courts have long recognized that copying software while reverse engineering is a fair use when done for purposes of fostering interoperability with independently created software, a body of law that Apple conveniently fails to mention.

As for the DMCA violation, Apple casts its lot with the likes of laser printer makers and garage door opener companies who argue that the DMCA entitles them to block interoperability with anything that hasn't been approved in advance. Apple justifies this by claiming that opening the iPhone to independently created applications will compromise safety, security, reliability, and swing the doors wide for those who want to run pirated software.

If this sounds like FUD, that's because it is. One need only transpose Apple's arguments to the world of automobiles to recognize their absurdity. Sure, GM might tell us that, for our own safety, all servicing should be done by an authorized GM dealer using only genuine GM parts. Toyota might say that swapping your engine could reduce the reliability of your car. And Mazda could say that those who throw a supercharger on their Miatas frequently exceed the legal speed limit.

But we'd never accept this corporate paternalism as a justification for welding every car hood shut and imposing legal liability on car buffs tinkering in their garages. After all, the culture of tinkering (or hacking, if you prefer) is an important part of our innovation economy.

Of course, many iPhone owners will be happy to choose solely from the applications that Apple is willing to approve, just like many Ford owners are happy relying exclusively on their local Ford dealer. But if you want to pop the hood, the DMCA surely shouldn't stand in your way.

Read More

Apple Says iPhone Jailbreaking is Illegal
Add Comment
Would you like to be notified when someone replies or adds a new comment?
Yes (All Threads)
Yes (This Thread Only)
iClarified Icon
Would you like to be notified when we post a new Apple news article or tutorial?
You must login or register to add a comment...
Rec2008 - February 14, 2009 at 11:56pm
Phh, they might own the software, but they cant tell you what you can and cannot install on your phone...they use the excuse that it drains the fcking big deal....just take the charger with you...if you (the iphone owner) damn care that much about the battery dont install jail broken apps....that simple. Apple should either started making adjustments to their phone, or leave it to jail community to fix and perfect what apple is too lazy to damn do... ROFL!!! Its like Microsoft saying you cant install yahoo messenger on your Vista OS... this is all just bullsh*t
istivan - February 14, 2009 at 7:49am
I understand that Apple has copyrights on its products but there is a point that Apple needs to understand. I reside in Malta (Europe) and when I bought mine I had to wait 3 days to start using my mobile phone, all Thanks and success goes to the creator of ZiPhone. There is one question behind this, Does Apple wants to increase the the Sales and Profit at the end of the year?, I'm sure the answer is yes. Then there is only one way out to do that. Make the iPhone compatable with all Networks around the World and 2nd the owner of the iPhone will decide what to install and what not to install. My iPhone is a 2G and I am running the latest firmware which is V2.2 and Apple is doing a really good job, doesn't crash, works perfect. Another thing I'd like to mention is, App Store has only few applications which I and other people can get, which are those listed as free. That is completely non-sense, why can't some countries around the world buy applications from App Store? Isn't this something that has to do with the copyrights as well, or is it Apple thinking that only American's live in this world. Well, Thanks to the creator of Cydia everyone can enjoy a whole lot of applications and live happy ever after. I don't think that this is fair on people who own an iPhone 2G or 3G, important to mention this is not referring to American iPhone users or Countries which are listed as Authorized Dealers and can buy applications through App Store or legally Unlock GSM Networks. This is referring to users that have Authorized Dealers like Malta but still are unable to buy applications from App Store or can't upgrade firmwares with ease, in other words we can't use iTunes to upgrade the firmware. Now I know that this message is completely useless because Apple will ignore all messages written to them because they will stick to their copyrights a stupid Law stuff. But there is something they need to be aware of, "HACKERS" , because they constantly provide service to countries with restrictions of Apple's Twisted Copyrights. I have no doubt that there will be an agreement on copyrights with European and Asian Countries in order that Apple will permit people to buy applications from App Store and can Legally register on iTunes and Legally Unlock GSM Networks and eliminate the hassle of Jailbreaking the iPhone. Again this is referring to countries that are unable to do this stuff. Thanks. Istivan Spiteri
Emad Shaabani
Emad Shaabani - February 13, 2009 at 6:19pm
This is really ridiculous. Ofcource I can do everything I want with my own mobile device. How can that be illegal? If I own it, then I do whatever I want with it! Is it illegal to clock my computer too? LOL
SunLizard - February 13, 2009 at 4:42pm
Apple has to respond in like kind in order to continue to do business as it has. It has not made any real attempt to block jailbreaking or unlocking (those motions to update baseband and change bootloading fuctionality have been largely to improve functionality/reliability. Not a direct attack on fixing the exploits used to jailbreak.) If Apple were serious about fixing holes and plugging backdoors they would have done so, they have the horsepower to do it. Also they've made no motions to take anyone to court over Jailbreaking or unlocking, if they thougt they had a legal leg to stand on they would have done so as well (Apple loves those letters...) What we have here is a corporation making a statement to re-inforce developers faith in thier business model, the AppStore. I think you will see a more of directed effort to protect against craculous and unauthorized app use, but you won't see anyone in court for the same reasons stated in the article above. Apple won't throw money into legal battles it stands to make pittance in financially... they learn from other folks mistakes (RIAA et al)
Telia - February 13, 2009 at 4:35pm
It will be interesting to see if iClarified will become like the Pirate Bay. After all, iClarified provides the most comprehensive jailbreaking tutorials
11 More Comments
Recent. Read the latest Apple News.
Tutorials. Help is here.
How to Fix 'No Matching Host Key Type Found' on Mac
How to Stream the World Cup Using a VPN
Where to Download macOS Ventura
AppleTV Firmware Download Locations
Where To Download iPhone Firmware Files From
Deals. Save on Apple devices and accessories.